Resources
How Many Leads Does a Law Firm Need to Sign a Case?
By the Broadside Co. team. Published November 16, 2026. Last updated November 16, 2026.
Direct answer: Divide the number of cases you want to sign by your lead-to-signed rate. To sign 10 cases a month at a 20% rate, you need about 50 leads. At 10%, you need 100. There is no single right rate: reported figures run from the single digits to about 30%, depending on lead type and how fast and well the firm follows up. Measure your own for 30 to 60 days and use the table below.
What is the formula?
Leads needed = cases you want to sign ÷ lead-to-signed rate.
| Signed cases wanted per month | 10% rate | 15% rate | 20% rate | 25% rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 50 | 34 | 25 | 20 |
| 10 | 100 | 67 | 50 | 40 |
| 20 | 200 | 134 | 100 | 80 |
Illustrative math, rounded up. Your rates will differ.
Example: you want 10 new workers' comp clients a month and you currently sign 15% of leads. You need about 67 leads a month.
Why is the lead-to-signed rate not one number?
It is the product of several steps, and each can leak:
- Contact rate. Share of leads you actually reach.
- Qualified rate. Share of reached leads that fit your case criteria.
- Sign rate. Share of qualified people who sign.
One industry guide reports these ranges for exclusive workers' comp leads: 55% to 70% reached, 50% to 65% qualified, and 60% to 75% of qualified people signing, which it puts at 18% to 30% of leads overall. Your own numbers will differ. Raise any step and the whole number moves.
What rate do firms report?
Reported benchmarks vary and mostly come from vendors and industry guides, not audited studies:
- One lead vendor reports that surveyed firms sign about one workers' comp client per 4.5 of its exclusive leads (about 22%).
- One industry guide reports 18% to 30% for exclusive workers' comp leads, and 10% to 25% for personal injury.
- A broader personal injury mix in one vendor case study signed 12 of 122 leads (9.84%).
- Guides commonly report shared leads converting lower than exclusive leads.
Because figures vary this much, use them only as a sanity check. Your own data beats any benchmark.
How does speed change the numbers?
Intake guides consistently stress the first few minutes. A person who just filled out a form may contact several firms, so the firm that reaches them first often has the advantage. Faster follow-up lifts your contact rate, which lifts the number of signed cases you get from the same leads.
How many leads can your intake team handle?
Leads needed is only half the planning question. Check capacity:
- How many calls can one intake person complete per day, including follow-up attempts?
- How many consultations can your attorneys take each week?
- What is your plan for after-hours and weekend leads?
Buying 200 leads for a team that can work 80 well lowers your signed rate and raises your cost per signed case. See what workers' comp leads cost.
What should you do if you need more cases?
Pick the cheapest fix first:
- Speed up follow-up. Call within minutes, text, and try again later the same day.
- Track each step. Contact, qualified, signed, by source.
- Tighten the lead screen. Ask the vendor to filter for what your intake rejects (state, injury timing, representation status).
- Then add volume. Buy more leads only when your numbers are healthy at current volume.
Our legal lead vendor checklist lists what to confirm with any vendor. Broadside Co. sells exclusive leads for motor vehicle accident, workers' compensation and employment law; see workers' comp leads.
Frequently asked questions
How many leads does a law firm need to sign one case? Divide 100 by your lead-to-signed percentage. At 20%, it is 5 leads per signed case; at 10%, it is 10. Reported rates range from the single digits to about 30%.
What is a good lead-to-signed rate for workers' comp? There is no universal benchmark. One industry guide reports about 18% to 30% for exclusive workers' comp leads. Shared leads are commonly reported lower. Measure your own.
How many leads should I buy in a pilot? Enough to see a pattern, commonly a few dozen. Small samples are noisy: signing 2 of 25 and 4 of 25 are different results, but both can be luck. Track results for 30 to 60 days before drawing a conclusion.
Why am I getting leads but not signed cases? Common causes are slow follow-up, leads that do not match your case criteria, wrong-state leads, and shared leads that other firms reached first. Track each step to find where they drop.
Does buying more leads raise my signed rate? No. More volume does not fix a slow or overloaded intake process, and it can lower your rate. Fix follow-up first.
What is a lead-to-signed rate? The share of leads that become signed clients. Signed cases ÷ leads received.
This guide is general information for law firms evaluating lead sources. It is not legal or financial advice, and it does not promise any result.
Sources
- LeadGen Economy, Workers Compensation Attorney Leads: The Complete Guide for 2026 (January 2026)
- Martindale-Avvo, LeadDirect for workers' comp and LeadDirect case studies
Replace both 2026-11-16 values with real ISO dates (for example 2026-12-01) at go-live. Keep them equal to the visible dates.