Skip to content
Book a 10-min call

Resources

What Do Workers' Comp Leads Cost? Cost Per Lead vs Cost Per Signed Case

By the Broadside Co. team. Published November 16, 2026. Last updated November 16, 2026.

Direct answer: Most published estimates put exclusive workers' compensation leads at roughly $100 to $300 per lead, depending on case type and state. Shared leads usually cost much less, and some case types and high-cost states cost more. Price per lead is only half the story. What matters is cost per signed case: the price of a lead divided by the share of leads your firm signs. A $200 lead that signs 25% of the time costs $800 per signed case. A $100 lead that signs 10% of the time costs $1,000.

Ranges below come from lead vendors and industry guides, not audited studies. Treat them as rough market guides and confirm with current vendor quotes.

How much does a workers' comp lead cost?

There is no single price. Sources differ because "lead" can mean a raw form fill, a phone-verified inquiry, or a lead sold to one firm only. One industry guide breaks it down like this:

What you are buyingReported costNotes
Exclusive lead, most workers' comp case typesRoughly $100 to $300Sold to one firm only
Higher-value case types (such as permanent disability, or third-party cases)Toward the top of that range, and above it for someThird-party cases are priced closer to personal injury
Shared leadOften 50% to 70% less than exclusiveSold to several firms, so more competition for contact
High-cost states (California, New York and Illinois are cited)About 20% to 40% moreState rules, case values and ad competition differ
Serious-injury leads (for example "surgery required")About 25% to 50% more than a minor-strain leadReported by the same guide
For comparison: personal injury, exclusiveRoughly $200 to $800Workers' comp is usually priced below personal injury

Why does the price vary so much?

  • Exclusive or shared. One firm per lead costs more than the same inquiry sold to several firms.
  • State. Workers' comp rules, case values and ad competition differ by state.
  • Case type and severity. A denied claim, a permanent disability claim and a minor injury are different cases with different value.
  • Screening. Leads checked for injury, employer notice, treatment status and whether the person already has a lawyer cost more, but waste less intake time.
  • Source. First-party leads come from the seller's own ads and funnel. Aggregated leads are collected from many publishers. See First-party vs aggregator leads and What is a lead aggregator?.

What is cost per signed case, and how do you calculate it?

Cost per signed case = cost per lead ÷ lead-to-signed rate.

The lead-to-signed rate is the share of leads that become signed clients. If you buy 100 leads and sign 20 cases, the rate is 20%.

Cost per lead10% signed15% signed20% signed25% signed30% signed
$100$1,000$667$500$400$333
$200$2,000$1,333$1,000$800$667
$300$3,000$2,000$1,500$1,200$1,000
$400$4,000$2,667$2,000$1,600$1,333

Illustrative math. Your rates will differ.

Read the table across a row: at the same price, doubling your signed rate cuts your cost per signed case in half. For many firms, better intake does more for cost than a cheaper lead. For help sizing volume, see How many leads does a law firm need?

What conversion rate should a firm expect?

Reported numbers vary widely, and almost all are self-reported by vendors:

  • One lead vendor reports that surveyed firms sign about one workers' comp client for every 4.5 of its exclusive leads (roughly 22%), and that 18% of consumers who connect through its service sign a retainer.
  • One industry guide reports 18% to 30% lead-to-signed for exclusive workers' comp leads, against 10% to 25% for personal injury.
  • A personal injury mix in one vendor case study signed 12 of 122 leads (9.84%).
  • Guides commonly report that shared leads convert lower and depend more on how fast the firm reaches the person.

The honest answer is to measure your own rate by source for 30 to 60 days, then use the table above.

Is a cheaper lead ever the better buy?

Sometimes. If your intake team is fast and has spare capacity, a lower-priced lead with a lower signed rate can still produce a good cost per signed case. If your team is stretched, a pricier exclusive lead that is easier to reach and qualify may cost less per signed case. The table tells you which, using your numbers.

What does a good cost per signed case look like?

It depends on what a signed case is worth to your firm. One vendor's own FAQ says a workers' comp firm might aim for under $900 per case, while a personal injury firm targeting high-value cases might accept $1,800. Treat those as examples, not targets. Your target comes from your average fee per case and your margin.

What else should you check before you buy?

  • Is each lead sold to one firm only, in writing?
  • Does each lead come with a consent record, such as a TrustedForm or Jornaya certificate? See TCPA consent for legal leads.
  • What is the return policy for wrong-state or already-represented leads?
  • How fast does the lead reach your team, and where does it land (CRM, text, email)?

Our legal lead vendor checklist covers all of these. Broadside Co. sells exclusive leads for motor vehicle accident, workers' compensation and employment law. Pricing depends on state and case type and is quoted on a short call: workers' comp leads.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a workers' comp lead cost on average? Most published estimates put exclusive workers' comp leads at roughly $100 to $300 per lead, with shared leads usually costing much less. These are vendor and industry-guide figures, not audited averages.

Are workers' comp leads cheaper than personal injury leads? Often, yes. One industry guide puts exclusive workers' comp leads at roughly $100 to $300 against $200 to $800 for personal injury. Case values and fee rules differ too, so compare cost per signed case, not cost per lead.

What is a good conversion rate for workers' comp leads? There is no universal benchmark. One industry guide reports about 18% to 30% for exclusive workers' comp leads, and shared leads are commonly reported lower. Your own intake speed and process move it more than the lead source does.

Should I pay per lead or per signed case? Pay per lead is common and simple. Pay per signed case shifts risk to the vendor and usually costs more per case. Whichever you choose, track cost per signed case by source.

Why do some vendors not publish prices? Prices change by state, case type and exclusivity, so many vendors quote on a call. That makes it harder to compare, which is why the math above is useful.

Does a higher lead price mean a better lead? Not by itself. Ask what the price includes (exclusivity, screening, consent record, return policy), then compare cost per signed case.

This guide is general information for law firms evaluating lead vendors. It is not legal or financial advice.

Sources

Replace both 2026-11-16 values with real ISO dates (for example 2026-12-01) at go-live. Keep them equal to the visible dates.